⭐⭐⭐☆☆
The Shining is one of the most overhyped horror films in the history of cinema. That is NOT me saying it is a bad film. I just don’t think I view cinema in the same frame as some other cinephiles.
From a technical standpoint, this is undeniable Stanley Kubrick excellence. The cinematography is gorgeous, precise, and icy. Those long tracking shots through the Overlook Hotel still feel ahead of their time, and the visual control is immaculate. Every hallway, every wide frame, every symmetrical composition reinforces a sense of unease and isolation. Kubrick knew exactly how to make a space feel oppressive.
Jack Nicholson is also fantastic. His performance is menacing, unpredictable, and unsettling from the jump. Even before Jack Torrance fully descends into madness, there’s something deeply off about him — and Nicholson leans into that discomfort perfectly. It’s a performance that has become iconic for a reason.
Where the film loses me is in its identity.
For me, The Shining feels trapped between two different movies. On one hand, it wants to be a claustrophobic psychological horror about a man slowly losing his mind under pressure and isolation. On the other, it wants to be a full-on paranormal story filled with ghosts, visions, and supernatural forces. Individually, both ideas are strong — but they never fully blend for me.
Instead of complementing each other, those elements feel like they’re competing. I never felt fully grounded in Jack’s psychological breakdown because the film keeps reminding me that supernatural forces may be pulling the strings. At the same time, the paranormal elements never felt as frightening as they should have, because so much attention is placed on Jack himself.
There’s also an emotional coldness to the film that kept me at a distance. Shelley Duvall’s performance works for the tone Kubrick was going for, but it often feels more grating than sympathetic. I understood the fear on screen, but I rarely felt it.
That said, the tension is effective. Kubrick knows how to stretch a moment, let silence linger, and allow dread to build slowly. The score, the sound design, and the visual pacing all work together to create an atmosphere that’s constantly uncomfortable — even if it didn’t fully scare me.
Final Rating: ⭐⭐⭐☆☆
The Shining is beautifully shot, expertly directed, and anchored by a truly great performance from Jack Nicholson. But for me, it never fully commits to the type of horror it wants to be. I admire it, I respect its influence, and I understand why it’s beloved — I just don’t connect with it the way many others do.
MovieTalk+ 
Leave a comment