⭐ ⭐ ☆ ☆ ☆
Directed by: Don Coscarelli
Starring: A. Michael Baldwin, Bill Thornbury, Reggie Bannister, Angus Scrimm
A young boy named Mike becomes convinced something is wrong at the local funeral home after witnessing strange events surrounding a recent death. What he discovers is a nightmare involving the mysterious Tall Man and something far more bizarre than your standard horror setup.
Phantasm is often talked about like a cult classic masterpiece. It’s weird. It’s ambitious. It’s dreamlike. And I totally respect what it’s trying to do.
But as a full viewing experience? It’s rough.
The standout here is Angus Scrimm as The Tall Man. His physical presence, that deep voice, and the iconic line delivery give the film an immediate horror identity. He feels like a legitimate genre villain.
The rest of the performances, though, feel very uneven. Some scenes land emotionally, especially between Mike and his brother, but other moments feel stiff and amateurish. It gives the movie a low-budget charm at times… and at other times it just feels low-budget.
Don Coscarelli clearly had imagination to burn. The movie feels like a nightmare — disjointed, surreal, sometimes confusing. There’s an eerie tone that works in isolated moments.
But the pacing is all over the place. Scenes drag. Transitions feel abrupt. It doesn’t build tension in a steady way — it kind of drifts.
You can see the creativity. You can feel the ambition. But it never fully comes together in a satisfying way.
The silver sphere is iconic. That’s not even debatable. The practical effects surrounding it are creative and memorable.
The score is also a highlight. It has that eerie, echoing synth sound that sticks with you and absolutely fits the strange atmosphere.
But beyond those elements, the editing feels messy and the cinematography is inconsistent. Some shots look great. Others look flat and rushed.
There are flashes of brilliance here. They just don’t carry the entire film.
Going in, I wanted to love this more than I did.
I appreciate originality in horror. I respect when something swings big and weird. And Phantasm definitely swings.
But for me, it never fully hooks me emotionally or scares me in a sustained way. It feels more like a collection of strange ideas than a cohesive horror story.
I get why it has a cult following. I just don’t connect with it the way many horror fans do.
I’d revisit it for the Tall Man and the iconic sphere scenes. But as a full sit-down experience? It’s not something I’m eager to return to.
Final Rating: ⭐ ⭐ ☆ ☆ ☆
Phantasm is imaginative and undeniably influential in cult horror circles. It introduced an iconic villain and one of the most recognizable horror props ever.
But influence doesn’t always equal enjoyment.
For me, it’s an interesting experiment that doesn’t fully deliver as a complete horror experience. Worth watching at least once if you’re a genre fan — just know it’s more strange than scary.
MovieTalk+ 
Leave a comment