⭐⭐☆☆☆
The Killing is a film that wears its influence on its sleeve — not always in a good way. Directed by Stanley Kubrick before he became a household name, it’s an early exercise in noir structure and stylistic ambition that ultimately leaves you appreciating the effort more than the result.
On paper, The Killing has all the right ingredients: a meticulously planned robbery, overlapping timelines, double crosses, and an ensemble of characters whose motives bleed into one another. This non-linear setup was ahead of its time, and in another movie it could’ve been compelling. But here, the technique feels more like a gimmick than a meaningful storytelling choice, and it often draws attention to itself in ways that interrupt narrative engagement rather than enhancing it.
Visually, the film shows occasional flashes of what would later become Kubrick’s signature precision — interesting framing, thoughtful use of shadows, and some ambitious camera moves. But those moments are too few and far between. Most of the movie feels flat, especially in scenes where the plot mechanics take priority over mood or character development.
The characters themselves struggle to generate sympathy or investment. Because so much of the movie is devoted to plotting, planning, and technical precision, there’s little room left for emotional depth. You never really understand the people whose lives are supposed to be upended by the robbery — you only understand what they’re doing and when they’re doing it.
The pacing is another sticking point. What should feel like tension often feels like repetition. The constant jumps between intersecting timelines dilute suspense instead of building it. Even when the story reaches its critical moments, you’re left thinking about the mechanics of how you got there more than why it matters.
I can see why The Killing is historically referenced as a precursor to later crime films — especially heist narratives that lean into structure and timing. But as an actual viewing experience, it rarely rises above that historical footnote. The influence is interesting; the execution is simply middling.
Final Rating: ⭐⭐☆☆☆
The Killing has a few sharp technical ideas and a clever structure in theory, but the emotional engagement and narrative payoff just aren’t there. It’s a film worth studying for early signs of a great filmmaker, but not one I’d personally recommend as a satisfying watch on its own. I think I just appreciate Kubrick’s earlier work more than I enjoy it.
MovieTalk+ 
Leave a comment